NEW LOCATION NOW OPEN!

Who we are / Becoming a Member / News / Links / Location / Contact us / Home / Hemp Info

Marijuana vs. alcohol: the straight-up dope
By: Kristen Thompson, The Voice (CN BC Edu), 11-03-05

A growing number of people in Vancouver believe marijuana laws are antiquated and unfair. According to all the research, it seems their complaints are not entirely unfounded.

We live in a country where social drinking, even involving minors, is quite acceptable. In high school most dads allow teenagers to have a beer at dinner or watching hockey. In university my parents loved my tales of drunken debauchery. I told those stories and people thought I was the life of the party. If I talked about pot, people would probably cringe.

Pot is still taboo, but SFU economics professor Stephen Easton says 23 per cent of Canadians admit to having done it. According to Maple Leaf Web, pot is the third most popular recreational drug after alcohol and tobacco, and B.C. has the highest user rate of all the provinces.

The California Research Advisory Panel has stated that "[pot] is responsible for less damage to society and the individual than are alcohol and cigarettes." So what's the deal?

Most studies indicate that pot has few adverse affects. Long-term use has been linked to bronchitis and lung disease. It affects perception and motor performance, which could impair driving. But that seems to be the extent of it.

Then there's alcohol, a totally legal yet far more harmful drug. The Canadian Bureau of Justice Statistics finds that more violent crimes are committed under the influence of alcohol than any other drug.

The Canadian Centre on Substance Abuse states that nearly half of all car crash deaths involve alcohol. In the United States it's the number one contributing factor in young deaths, and accounts for a quarter of all youth hospital visits.

Pot on the other hand, was involved in less than two per cent of drug-related visits to the hospital in 1994. And anyone who has hung around with a giggling stoner knows that smoking marijuana decreases, rather than increases, aggression.

In 2002, Stats Canada found that 600,000 Canadians were addicted to alcohol. This is compared to studies collected by the Drug Policy Alliance that indicate marijuana is non-addictive. It finds that when it comes to crime, most pot smokers cause no other misdeed than the possession of the pot itself.

And what about the belief that legalization will only encourage use?

In the Netherlands, people over 18 can legally buy and use cannabis. Yet the adult usage rate is equivalent to the United States, and among young people, rates are actually lower.

According to a 1994 study by California doctor Dale Gieringer, a marijuana expert, the belief that pot kills brain cells came from a flawed experiment by Dr. Robert Heath back in 1980.

In his experiment, Heath observed structural changes (not actual cell death) in the brain cells of animals exposed to high doses of marijuana smoke. This work was never replicated and has since been discredited by all other studies.

I've never woken up hung-over after a night of smoking pot, and the only regret it's ever caused me is a little post-brownie binge guilt.

It seems the only difference between a few pints and a few tokes is a handful of unfounded presumptions and an outdated law.

© 2005 H.U.M.A.N.: Hemp Users Medical Access Network - Toronto Medical Marijuana